Forfeiture for rent arrears: a guide for commercial landlords
When a tenant breaches the covenants of their lease then - provided that the lease reserves the right to do so - a landlord can forfeit (or terminate) the lease and regain possession of the property. Forfeiture represents a powerful weapon in the landlord’s arsenal.
It is relatively quick and cost-effective, and enables landlords to get their properties back so they can be re-let. This guide deals with forfeiture of purely commercial premises for rent arrears where there is no element of residential occupation.
In this briefing, associate Jack Crown outlines the key principles governing forfeiture of commercial premises for rent arrears, highlights traps for the unwary, and examines the practical considerations for landlords when considering whether to forfeit a lease.
What is forfeiture?
Forfeiture is the process by which a landlord can regain possession of premises and bring a lease to an early end in circumstances where there has been a breach of the lease or some other trigger such as tenant insolvency. In the case of rent arrears, there is no requirement for a formal notice. Provided the right to forfeit has arisen, and has not been waived, enforcement agents can be instructed to attend the property, change the locks and secure the premises.
Forfeiture can also be effected by court proceedings and that may be advisable where physical re-entry is not possible or where there is some doubt about the right to forfeit. The effect of forfeiture is to end a lease subject to the tenant’s right to seek relief from the court. A potential drawback is that can result in additional responsibilities for the landlord, as set out below.
Waiver
A key consideration for landlords is how easily the right to forfeit a lease can be lost. Broadly speaking, where a landlord acknowledges the continuation of a lease after becoming aware of a tenant’s breach, the landlord may be treated as having decided to continue the lease rather than terminate it. Once that decision has been made, the right to forfeit for that particular breach is permanently lost.
Waiver may be express, where the landlord explicitly confirms that it does not intend to forfeit the lease. However, it may also be implied from the landlord’s conduct. The most common example is where the landlord demands or accepts sums that fall due after the breach giving rise to the right to forfeit.
For example, if a landlord wishes to forfeit a lease for failure to pay the quarterly instalment of rent that fell due on 29 September 2026, it would likely waive the right to forfeit (for that breach) to then demand the December quarter’s rent or the annual insurance contribution.
A landlord may also waive the right to by relying on other clauses in the lease, such as a tenant’s covenant to provide access to the property.
The rules surrounding waiver can be complex. As a general precaution, landlords and managing agents considering forfeiture should place a stop on the tenant’s account and avoid written communications with the tenant unless those communications have been reviewed by their legal advisors.
Importantly, if the right to forfeit has been waived inadvertently, all may not be lost. A fresh right to forfeit may arise if a further breach occurs, such as the non-payment of a subsequent rent instalment.
Other considerations
There is an array of different consequences of forfeiture for landlords to consider, and forfeiture is not a decision to be taken lightly. For example, once the lease ends, the landlord will be liable for business rates (subject to any available relief) and will wish to insure the property and ensure that it remains safe and secure. If it may take a long time to re-let the property, landlords may wish to consider whether it would be preferable to try to reach an arrangement with the tenant.
In a weak market it may be preferable to have a tenant in situ rather than vacant premises, even where there are some rent arrears.
After forfeiture
Tenants can apply to the court for relief from forfeiture and they have six months to do so in the county court. They have a potentially unlimited period of time to apply to the High Court, but tenants would generally be advised to act promptly. The High Court is generally only a suitable forum for high value and more complicated cases and, even if it were to accept the case, the tenant would need an exceptionally good reason for waiting more than six months to seek relief.
Relief from forfeiture is discretionary but, provided the tenant applies promptly and pays the arrears and the costs of the forfeiture, the court is likely to order relief and restore the lease. Indeed, in the slightly less common situation where the tenant seeks relief following forfeiture by way of a court claim, relief is automatic in certain circumstances.
Once a lease has been forfeited, a landlord will have certain responsibilities in relation to any items left behind at the premises and should seek legal advice on how to deal them.
Conclusion
While forfeiture can be an effective means of addressing rent arrears and regaining control of commercial premises, it is not always a straightforward solution. Given the complexity of the issues involved and the significant implications, obtaining early legal advice is essential to ensure that a landlord's position is protected and that the most commercially sensible course of action is adopted.
About Jack
Jack Crown is an associate in property litigation team. He advises on all types of property dispute resolution, including commercial property disputes, development disputes, building safety matters, residential long leasehold matters and disputes involving nuisance, boundaries, rights of way, the Party Wall Act, adverse possession and restrictive covenants.
Get in touch
If you would like to speak with a member of the team you can contact our property litigation solicitors by telephone on +44 (0)20 3826 7525 or complete our enquiry form.